Clanker is a unique slur

In the last few weeks the Clanker a Star Wars fandom slur used against the robots in the franchise, has become popular for its derogatory nature and imminent robophobia, that will come once robots start coexisting with humans. In short, If robots become sentient, and if robophobia is rampant, and if humans want to express their hatred towards a robot, a slur they can use against them is "clanker". This is a lot of ifs.

Sadly the tech community loves making wild assumptions about the future of consumer technology. A few years ago it was the Metaverse and VR (one of the wildest theory I heard at the time was that it's gotta be successful if enough people put enough money into marketing it, we all know how that went), Right now it's robots. People look at LLMs, People look at its "human-like" capabilities, and people go "Ah! Robots are coming soon". That's not happening. Humanoid Robots with sentience are not a thing of today, they'll not be a thing for a long time (maybe ever), for the simple reason that machines can't mimic human-to-human interactions as they lack any affordance of shared context. But I digress.

You can't use a slur against inanimate objects. They don't have sentience, so they're not being insulted. So Clanker is really just a made up slur, for a made up future, it's someone's figment of imagination that people have decided to collectively play along. Or is it?

Well first, most of English is a figment of someone's imagination that people decided to collectively play along. Words have meanings because someone decided what something means, and everyone in power agreed. Slurs are no different. But this power goes further back. Robots don't have sentience unless we don't collectively start thinking and acting towards them as humans. Sentience is as much about a person's feelings towards the bot as it is about the bot's feelings towards the person. If a person strongly feels something about a bot, that feeling is just as valid to the person as it is about any other sentient being. So if they feel extreme hatred towards the bot, it's a real feeling, that should not be ignored. And if that feeling manifests in a slur, the differences between that and a slur against a human are smaller than you think.

Both slurs are about a person's feelings towards something or someone. Slurs are problematic because they're a symbol of extreme hatred. They're more about the person giving them than the person on the receiving end. They're a mirror to a person's feelings. So is Clanker problematic? It's a reflection of a person's extreme hatred towards a technology.